Probably Stolen Best Weapons: What Actually Matters

Probably Stolen best weapons guide: why there is no public tier list, which firearm roles matter, permit costs, ammo, 3D Printer attachments and mod risks.

Last Updated: 2026-11-09

Quick answer. There is no public, verified tier list of named Probably Stolen weapons. The game confirms firearms, ammunition, a Class 1 permit, 3D Printed pistols and attachments, and weapon mods, but it does not publish weapon stats or model names in a way we can rank. The best "weapon" is therefore a role: a legal, permitted firearm you can feed, maintain, and replace without wrecking your margin.

That answer is less exciting than a ranked list, but it is the honest one. This page covers what the game actually documents, which roles matter for a shopkeeper, and how permits, inspections, and mods change the calculation.

Inspecting a weapon and permit stock at the shop counter
Inspecting a weapon and permit stock at the shop counter

No invented weapon names

You will find videos and posts that rank guns by name. We have not found an official stat sheet that supports those rankings. Treat named "best weapon" claims as community opinion unless the developer publishes numbers.

What the game confirms

The store page and our own testing notes confirm these pieces:

System Confirmed detail Why it matters
Firearms Guns exist as stock and equipment The Gunsmith start begins with firearms
Ammunition Ammo is a separate item; 10mm appears in supply crates A gun without ammo is a display piece
Class 1 permit Required to trade firearms legally Without it, the same stock is contraband
Permit cost 500 Cozy, 1,500 Normal, 2,000 Hard The permit changes the break-even point
3D Printer Prints pistols and attachments with recipe chips Replacement parts and custom builds
Weapon mods Mods can be installed on legal guns An illegal mod can make a legal gun a problem
Inspections Stock must match the permit Mismatches mean confiscation risk

What the game does not confirm is a list of model names with damage, range, or fire-rate values. Our crime and investigation guide→ covers the permit and inspection side in more detail. The machinery guide→ covers the 3D Printer and recipe chips.

The four roles that matter

Instead of ranking models, rank the jobs a shopkeeper needs done.

This is the gun you can show an inspector without a problem. It should be covered by your Class 1 permit, use common ammunition, and stay compatible with legal mods. Its job is not to be the strongest; it is to be the least likely to cost you a fine or a confiscated shipment.

On Normal, the permit costs 1,500 credits. That is a real chunk of early capital. If you are not committed to the gun trade, the permit is a worse purchase than stock you can actually sell. If you are committed, buy it before you buy a large gun shipment, not after.

2. The printed replacement

The 3D Printer can produce pistols and attachments when you have the right recipe chip. The advantage is supply: you are not dependent on a supplier's stock for a part you can make. The disadvantage is that printing takes machine time and inputs that could go into another product.

Use the printer for parts you lose or wear out, not for a speculative gun collection. A printed replacement keeps a legal sale alive; a shelf full of printed guns ties up capital and invites inspection attention.

Attachments are where a "best weapon" argument usually starts. A mod can improve a gun's handling or value, but the permit system cares about what is installed. A legal firearm with an illegal mod can still fail an inspection. Before you install anything, decide whether the gun is for sale, for display, or for personal defense.

Our display case guide→ recommends one licensed showpiece rather than a wall of risky stock. That advice applies to weapons more than any other category.

4. The contraband option

Unlicensed firearms carry higher margins and higher risk. Inspections can confiscate them, and the reputation hit can outlast the sale. This is a legitimate playstyle, but it is not a "best weapon" answer. It is a different business model with a different failure state.

If you take this route, separate the stock from your legal inventory and keep enough cash to absorb a seizure. Do not mix contraband into a display case that an inspector can read as a permit violation.

Ammo and upkeep

A gun with no ammo is a prop. The supply-crate table lists 10mm ammunition alongside bandages, keycards, flashbangs, and smoke grenades. That makes 10mm a practical baseline for a shop that wants to sell a working package rather than a wall hanger.

Keep a small buffer of ammo for the guns you display or carry, and do not let a customer buy the last box before you have tested the gun. The store page does not publish damage values, so ammo efficiency is a matter of observation, not math we can quote.

Permit economics

The permit is the single biggest variable in a weapon-focused run. Compare the three difficulties:

Difficulty Vendor permit Best use
Cozy 500 Learning the gun trade with low risk
Normal 1,500 A committed side business
Hard 2,000 Only after another income stream is stable

On Thin Margins, the permit and the higher supplier costs can eat the entire gun margin. Run the money guide→ math before you commit. A gun shop that cannot pay rent is not a gun shop; it is a liquidation sale.

Buy the permit before the stock

A shipment you cannot legally display is a liability. The permit turns stock into inventory. Buy it first, then buy guns that match it.

What we would test first

If you want to build a weapon-focused run, test in this order:

  1. Start Gunsmith so you begin with a permit, firearms, and ammunition.
  2. Sell one legal gun and one ammo bundle to learn the customer flow.
  3. Print one attachment and confirm the permit still matches the build.
  4. Add a second legal gun only after the first sale clears rent.
  5. Try contraband on a separate save, not on the run you care about.

This order keeps the experiment cheap. It also tells you whether the gun trade suits your playstyle before you spend 2,000 credits on a Hard-mode permit.

Best weapons FAQ

What is the best weapon in Probably Stolen?

There is no verified named ranking. The best role is a legal, permitted firearm with common ammo and a clean mod setup. Damage and range values are not published in a form we can rank.

Do I need a permit to own a gun?

The game treats firearms as legal with the right permit. The Gunsmith start includes a Class 1 permit. Without one, the same stock is contraband and can be confiscated.

Can I 3D print weapons?

The 3D Printer can produce pistols and attachments when you have the matching recipe chip. It is a supply solution, not a free weapon generator.

Are weapon mods worth it?

Mods can improve a legal gun, but an illegal mod can make the whole gun a permit problem. Mod for a specific sale or display role, not for a number you cannot verify.

What ammo should I stock?

10mm appears in security supply crates and is a practical baseline. Stock ammo that matches the guns you actually sell, and keep a small buffer for testing.

Official source: Steam store page ↗ for the Gunsmith start and permit systems; Steam news hub ↗ for balance patches; Steam community hub ↗ for developer replies on inspections.