Probably Stolen Leroy: Fake Inspector Choices and Rewards
Leroy is a fake Security inspector in Probably Stolen. His five outcomes, the 300-credit bounty, the day-14 trigger and the safest way to handle the search.
Leroy is a wanted man who walks into your shop dressed as a Security inspector. He arrives once, at random, from day 14, and reporting him pays a 300-credit bounty plus 5 Security reputation. If you let him search, he can confiscate mid-level contraband and stolen goods, but he cannot fine you, arrest you or change your Security reputation. The safest play is to keep your counter and display case clean from day 14 onward and report him before the search starts.
He is one of the few visitors who punishes you for being polite. Treat the inspection as a trap, not a routine check.

Leroy is a fake. Report him before he searches for 300 credits and 5 Security reputation. If your counter or display case holds contraband or stolen goods when he arrives, he skips the dialogue and searches immediately, and you lose the chance to report or send him away. He takes mid-level and stolen goods, leaves low-level contraband, and never fines or arrests you.
Who Leroy is and when he shows up
Leroy is a wanted NPC with a 300-credit bounty. He poses as a Security inspector and uses the same opening lines as a real one. The difference is in what he can actually do: a real inspection can fine you, change your reputation and leave a record, while Leroy's search has no fine, no arrest and no paperwork. The crime and investigation page→ explains how real inspections work. The night log reveals who he was after he leaves, which is useful for learning the pattern but useless for getting your stock back.
His trigger is day 14 or later, at random. He comes once per run. That timing is why new players meet him right after they have built up a shelf of stock and before they have learned to read inspection dialogue.
There is one early tell. Once you have Security's VIP perk, real inspections stop. Leroy does not know that. He opens with a line about this inspection being special, ordered from the top, which is exactly what a real inspector would not say under the perk. If you have the perk and hear "special inspection", you are talking to Leroy.
The five outcomes
Leroy's encounter has five endings. The reward is the same for the two report routes; the difference is whether the goods he already took are still in your shop.
| Route | What you do | Result |
|---|---|---|
| A. Caught the impostor | Report him before the search | 300 credits, +5 Security reputation, nothing seized |
| B. Caught after the search | Let him search, then report during the result lines | 300 credits, +5 Security reputation, taken goods stay gone |
| C. Robbed | Let him search, he finds mid-level or stolen goods, let him leave | Goods destroyed, no fine, no reputation change |
| D. A clean search | Let him search, he finds nothing, let him leave | Nothing gained or lost, not even the 3 reputation a real clean inspection gives |
| E. Sent away | Send him away at the door | No search, no penalty, he does not return |
Route A is the best outcome because it pays the bounty without losing stock. Route B pays the same but only after he has taken something, so it is a consolation prize. Route E is the safe fallback if your counters are clean and you do not want to risk the report timing.
Why the "report before search" window closes
If contraband or stolen goods are on your counter or display case when Leroy arrives, he goes straight into the inspection. You cannot send him away and you cannot report him at that point. The dialogue that would let you choose is skipped because he has already seen the stock.
That is the whole trap. Players keep a display case full of stolen goods to attract customers, then get a fake inspection on a random day and lose the chance to collect the bounty. The fix is boring but effective: from day 14, keep the counter and display case clean of contraband and stolen goods, and store that stock in the back room or the hidden stash until you have dealt with him.
The hidden stash is not a perfect shield either. Leroy searches the hidden stash if the poster is pulled. If your stash is exposed, he can reach it. Close the stash before you open the shop for the day.
Leroy leaves low-level contraband alone. That is a quirk, not a licence to fill your counter with it. Mid-level contraband and stolen goods are taken, and the risk is not worth the shelf space for a few credits of margin.
What he searches
Leroy's search covers five places:
- Your inventory.
- The counter.
- The display case.
- The trash.
- The hidden stash, if the poster is pulled.
He does not check permits or paperwork, because he is not a real inspector. He is looking for things he can take. That makes the search predictable: anything stolen or mid-level contraband in those five places is at risk, and anything in a closed stash or a back-room container he cannot open is not.
The trash check catches players who dump a stolen item to avoid a real inspection. Against Leroy, dumping does not help if the item is still in the bin when he searches. Sell it, stash it, or do not buy it.
How to handle him step by step
- Check the opening line. From day 14, treat every inspection as Leroy until proven otherwise. If you have the VIP perk and he says "special", you know.
- Look at your counter and display case. If they hold contraband or stolen goods, the report option is already gone. Accept the search and salvage what you can.
- If the counters are clean, report him before the search. That is route A: 300 credits and 5 Security reputation.
- If you let him search, report during the result lines. The button stops working on his last line, so press it before the dialogue ends. That is route B: same reward, lost goods stay lost.
- If you do nothing, he leaves with what he found. That is route C, and the goods are destroyed.
- If you want no risk at all, send him away. Route E costs you the bounty but keeps the stock and ends his visit permanently.
A clean search (route D) gives you nothing, not even the small reputation a real clean inspection would give. If you have already let him in and he finds nothing, you have lost the bounty for no benefit. Reporting is almost always better than a polite clean search.
Is reporting Leroy bad for reputation?
No. Reporting him gives +5 Security reputation and no faction loss. The community guides that cover the encounter list no Lower Levels penalty either. That makes him one of the few wanted visitors you can report without paying a hidden cost.
The one thing you lose is a potential repeat customer, and Leroy does not come back after being sent away. Since he only visits once, there is no long-term relationship to protect. Take the bounty.
FAQ
When does Leroy appear? From day 14 onward, at random, once per run.
How much is Leroy's bounty? 300 credits, plus 5 Security reputation when you report him.
Can Leroy fine or arrest you? No. His search has no fine, no arrest and no reputation change. He can only take goods.
What happens if you send Leroy away? He leaves without searching, with no penalty, and does not return.
How do you know it is Leroy before the search? With the Security VIP perk, real inspections stop, so his "special inspection" line gives him away. Without the perk, the night log confirms it after he leaves.
Does Leroy take low-level contraband? No. He leaves low-level contraband alone. He takes mid-level contraband and stolen goods.
Official source: Steam store page ↗ for the Security and inspection systems; Steam news hub ↗ for inspection fixes; Stolen Ledger Leroy route map ↗ for the five outcomes and day-14 trigger; GameWith Leroy page ↗ for the no-penalty report and specialization notes.

